Perfect Competition vs Monopolistic Competition

Difference Between Perfect Competition vs Monopolistic Competition

Perfect competition is a market structure in which there are numerous sellers in the market, selling similar goods that are produced/manufactured using a standard method and each firm has all information regarding the market and price, which is known as a perfectly competitive market. Monopolistic competition is a type of imperfect market structure. In a monopolistic competition structure, a number of sellers sell similar products but not identical products. Products or services offered by sellers are substitutes of each other with certain differences. A market can be described as a place where buyers and sellers meet, directly or through a dealer for transactions.

Flowchart shows Market Structure

What is the Perfect Competition?

• The entry and exit to such a market are free.
• This is a theoretical situation of the market, where the competition is at its peak.
• The firms don’t have price control, so they don’t have a pricing policy. The buyer or seller doesn’t have control over prices. Therefore, a seller has to accept prices determined by market supply and demand forces.
• The product offered by all sellers is the same in all respect so no firm can increase its price and if a firm tries to increase the price then it will lose its all demand to the competitors.

What is Monopolistic Competition?

• Monopolistic competition has features of both the market structures perfect competition and monopoly. This kind of market structure is found in real life.
• Firms are selling products with certain differences in quality, quantity, etc features, so firms have pricing control and pricing policies of firms that are in place.
• Entry and exit into the industry are easy because of fewer barriers.
• Product differentiation is one of the features of monopolistic competition, where products are differentiated from each other on the basis of quality or brand.
• One of the differentiating parameters of monopolistic competition is, it has a Highly elastic demand curve.

Just a few examples of monopolistic competition include:

• Bars/nightclubs
• Coffee shops
• Grocery stores
• Pharmacies
• Gas stations
• Hotels
• Hardware/home improvement stores
• Furniture stores
• Landscaping/lawn care services
• Car washes
• Automotive service companies
• Dry cleaners

Monopolistic competition is a practical example of a market scenario, it can be seen around us. Types of products or services provided by each market participant are differentiated. Products or services can be differentiated in many ways such as brand recognition, product quality, value addition to products or services or product placing, etc.

Perfect Competition vs Monopolistic Competition (Infographics)

Below is the top 10 difference between Perfect Competition and Monopolistic Competition:

Key differences between Perfect Competition vs Monopolistic Competition

Both Perfect Competitions vs Monopolistic Competition are popular choices in the market; let us discuss some of the major Difference Between Perfect Competition and Monopolistic Competition:

1. A market structure, where there are numerous sellers, selling close substitute goods/services to the buyers, is monopolistic competition. A market structure, where there are many sellers selling similar products/services to the buyers, is perfect competition.
2. In perfect competition, the product offered is standardized whereas in monopolistic competition product differentiation is there.
3. In monopolistic competition, every firm offers products at its own price. In perfect competition, the demand and supply forces determine the price for the whole industry and every firm sells its product at that price.
4. Entry and Exit are comparatively easy in perfect competition than in monopolistic competition.
5. In monopolistic competition, average revenue (AR) is greater than the marginal revenue (MR), i.e. to increase sales the firm has to lower down its price. On the other hand, the average revenue (AR) and marginal revenue (MR) curve coincide with each other in perfect competition.
6. Monopolistic competition, that exists practically. On the other hand, perfect competition is an imaginary situation that does not exist in reality.
7. The demand curve as faced by a monopolistic competitor is not flat, but rather downward-sloping, which means that the monopolistic competitor can raise its price without losing all of its customers or lower the price and gain more customers. Since there are substitutes, the demand curve facing a monopolistically competitive firm is more elastic than that of a perfect competition where there are no substitutes. If a monopolist raises its price, some consumers will choose not to purchase its product—but they will then need to buy a completely different product. However, when a monopolistic competitor raises its price, some consumers will choose not to purchase the product at all, but others will choose to buy a similar product from another firm. If a monopolistic competitor raises its price, it will not lose as many customers as would a monopoly competitive firm, but it will lose more customers than would a monopoly that raised its prices.

Perfect Competition vs Monopolistic Competition Comparion Table

Below is the topmost Comparison between Perfect Competition vs Monopolistic Competition are as follows –

Basic of Comparison	Perfect competition	Monopolistic Competition
Number of seller/buyers	Many	Many
Type of good/services offered	Homogeneous	Differentiated
Does firm have pricing control over their own prices?	No – Price Takers	Yes – some pricing power
Is marketing/branding important?	No	Yes – Key non-price competition
Are entry barriers zero, low or high?	Zero entry Barrier	Low entry Barrier
Does this market structure lead to allocated efficiency in the long run?	Yes, Price = MC	Not Quite (P>MC)
Does this market structure lead to productive efficiency in the long run?	Yes	No
Situation	Unrealistic	Realistic
Demand curve slope	Horizontal, perfectly elastic	Downward sloping, relatively elastic
A relation between Average Revenue (AR) and Marginal Revenue (MR)	Average Revenue = Marginal Revenue	Average Revenue > Marginal Revenue.

Conclusion

After reading the all above points, it is quite clear that perfect competition vs monopolistic competition is different in many aspects, the major difference can be understood by the fact monopolistic competition has features of both monopoly and perfect competition.

The principal difference between these two is that in the case of perfect competition the firms are price takers, whereas in monopolistic competition the firms are price makers. Perfect competition is not realistic, it is a hypothetical situation, on the other hand, monopolistic competition is a practical scenario.

Recommended Articles

This has been a guide to the top difference between Perfect Competition vs Monopolistic Competition. Here we also discuss the perfect Competition vs Monopolistic Competition key differences with infographics, and comparison table. You may also have a look at the following articles to learn more

1. Revenue vs Earnings
2. Investment vs savings
3. Financial Accounting vs Management Accounting
4. Revenue vs Sales