EDUCBA

EDUCBA

MENUMENU
  • Free Tutorials
  • Free Courses
  • Certification Courses
  • 250+ Courses All in One Bundle
  • Login

Cumulative Voting

Home » Finance » Blog » Corporate Finance Basics » Cumulative Voting

Cumulative Voting

What is Cumulative Voting?

The term “cumulative voting” refers to the multi-voting system that some organisations use to provide better representation to the shareholders, especially the minority shareholders. In cumulative voting, the shareholders hold voting rights equivalent to the product of the number of shares they own (assuming one vote per share) and the number of available director positions. In this type of voting, the shareholders can distribute their votes in whatever proportion they deem fit. In the US, some of the states mandate the use of cumulative voting in corporate governance. It is also known as multi-voting, weighted voting, and accumulation voting.

Purpose of Cumulative Voting

In general, the shareholders are required to vote on many critical matters of the company, which also include the selection of the members of the corporate board. Typically, the shareholders are entitled to one vote per share that they own at the time when a particular matter has come up for voting. Consequently, the minority shareholders tend to have limited say in the selection of the corporate board members in case of a straight voting method, while the majority shareholders have more votes owing to their higher shareholding, and thus their opinions get preference. However, many believe that this setup suppresses the opinion of the minority shareholders, which is considered to be a problem, and this is where cumulative voting comes into play to save the day.

Start Your Free Investment Banking Course

Download Corporate Valuation, Investment Banking, Accounting, CFA Calculator & others

In this, the shareholders have votes that are equivalent to multiple times that of the straight voting system, which enhances the power of the minority shareholders such that they can influence the results of the election of board members. Basically, a shareholder can allocate multiple votes to a single candidate, and in this way, he/ she can influence the outcome more meaningfully.

Most S&P 500 companies don’t employ the cumulative voting system. In fact, Hewlett-Packard used the cumulative voting system in the past. But in 2016, Hewlett-Packard rejected the system stating that it is incompatible and conflicting with the majority vote standard for the election of directors. Essentially, the system’s very purpose was considered the problem because it allowed the relatively small number of shareholders to elect the directors who the majority shareholders didn’t support.

Example of Cumulative Voting

Let us assume that John is one of the minority shareholders of a company and has 100 shares. The company is currently having an election for five directors. Under the straight voting system, John can allocate a maximum of 100 votes for each candidate totaling 500 votes (100 votes for each of the five candidates). On the other hand, under the cumulative voting system, John can either allocate a maximum of 500 votes to a single candidate or 250 each to two candidates or divide the votes whichever way he wants. Effectively, John can allocate five times the votes to a single candidate than what he can do in the case of a straight voting system. This is how a cumulative voting system provides more power to the minority shareholders.

Impact of Cumulative Voting

A cumulative voting system is advantageous to the minority shareholders and boosts their ability to influence the election outcome. Unlike straight voting, cumulative voting allows the shareholders to allocate all the votes to a single candidate. Let us see how minority shareholders benefit from cumulative voting. Say there is a minority shareholder who owns 15 shares in a company, and the majority shareholder owns the remaining 85 shares. If there is an election for four directors, the minority shareholder will get 60 votes, and the majority shareholder will get 340 votes – a total of 400 votes. In the case of straight voting, the minority shareholder can cast a maximum of 15 votes for his/ her favorite candidate, and this might not be enough for the candidate to be elected. In this case, the same minority shareholder can cast all the 60 votes for that single candidate and force the issue with more decisive power. The effect of the extra 45 votes on the final outcome captures the impact of cumulative voting.

Popular Course in this category
Sale
Business Valuation Training (16 Courses)16 Online Courses | 80+ Hours | Verifiable Certificate of Completion | Lifetime Access
4.5 (8,917 ratings)
Course Price

View Course

Related Courses
Equity Research Training (17 Courses)Project Finance Training (8 Courses with Case Studies)

Advantages

Some of the major advantages are as follows:

  • It is useful in empowering minority shareholders.
  • Under this, several minority shareholders join forces to have a very good shot at electing their desired candidates.
  • It helps in preventing the selection of the same type of candidates by the majority shareholders.

Disadvantages

Some of the major disadvantages are as follows:

  • This can lead to uncertainty within the organization.
  • It is less useful in the absence of any proper communication channel in the organization.
  • A small section of shareholders can work in cohorts to misuse the system and make it almost impossible to remove a director once elected.

Key Takeaways

Some of the key takeaways of the article are:

  • It is used in the election of the board of directors.
  • The entitlement of votes can be determined as the product of the number of shares owned and the number of directors to be elected.
  • In cumulative voting, the shareholders can either cast all their votes for one candidate or split the votes among the multiple candidates.
  • Most S&P 500 companies don’t use the cumulative voting system for electing their board of directors.

Conclusion

So, it can be seen that organizations can use cumulative voting to protect the interest of minority shareholders in the selection of the board of directors. If the minority shareholders use the voting system effectively, they can have higher chances of electing their preferred candidate.

Recommended Articles

This is a guide to Cumulative Voting. Here we also discuss the definition, purpose, examples, and impact of Cumulative Voting along with its advantages and disadvantages. You may also have a look at the following articles to learn more –

  1. Non-Cumulative Preference Shares
  2. Owner’s Equity
  3. Callable Preferred Stock
  4. Preferred Shares

All in One Financial Analyst Bundle (250+ Courses, 40+ Projects)

250+ Online Courses

40+ Projects

1000+ Hours

Verifiable Certificates

Lifetime Access

Learn More

0 Shares
Share
Tweet
Share
Primary Sidebar
Finance Blog
  • Corporate Finance Basics
    • BPO vs KPO
    • C Corporation
    • Brick and Mortar
    • Business Entity Concept
    • Bounced Check
    • Capital Maintenance
    • Bridge Financing
    • Business Exit Strategy
    • Callable Bonds
    • Affiliated Companies
    • Certified Check
    • Chattel Mortgage
    • Contingent Beneficiary
    • Debt Collector
    • Closed Corporation
    • Cumulative Voting
    • Consumer Loan
    • Commercial Loans
    • Collateralization
    • Commercial Credit
    • Collection Agency
    • Classification of Financial Markets
    • Class Action Lawsuits
    • Prudence Concept in Accounting
    • Calmar Ratio
    • Asset Classes
    • Audit Evidence
    • Contingent Liability
    • Employee Stock
    • Financial Liabilities
    • Incurred Cost
    • Partial Income Statement
    • Deferred Tax Asset
    • Tax Fraud
    • Non-Operating Income
    • Variable Costing
    • Mixed Cost
    • Prime Cost
    • Regressive Tax Examples
    • Unqualified Opinion of Auditor
    • Bonds Payable
    • Class A Shares
    • Contingent Liability Example
    • Contingent Shares
    • Contributed Capital
    • Brownfield Investment
    • Internal Audit
    • Indirect Taxes
    • Fund Management
    • Fixed Cost
    • Debt Equity Swap
    • Cash Flow Hedge
    • Risk Shifting
    • High Yield Investments
    • General Obligation Bond
    • Forward Market
    • Box Spread
    • Fixed Income Trader
    • Trade Discount
    • Quick Assets
    • Notes Payable
    • Revenue Bonds
    • Euribor
    • Settlement Date
    • Short Covering
    • Short Selling
    • Dividend Examples
    • Time to Market
    • Junior Accountant
    • Commodity Derivatives
    • Flash Report
    • Idle Time
    • Leasehold Improvement
    • Product Portfolio
    • Risk Parity
    • Branch Accounting
    • Credit Enhancement
    • Basis Trading
    • At the Money
    • Collateralized Mortage Obligation
    • Accounts Receivable
    • Long Term Investments
    • Negative Goodwill
    • Recourse Factoring
    • Residual Value
    • Short Term Loan
    • Tax Exempt
    • Audit Report Format
    • Cash Investment
    • 457 Plan
    • Audit Procedure
    • Audit Materiality
    • Audit Committee
    • Asset Allocation
    • Non-Cash Expenses
    • Dividend Policy Types
    • Credit Terms
    • Dividend Payable
    • Profit Center
    • Absorption Costing
    • Final Dividend
    • Hybrid Securities
    • Other Current Assets
    • Simple Random Sample
    • Dependency Ratio
    • Effective Duration
    • Loan to Value Ratio
    • Inventory Turnover Ratio
    • Advantages of Ratio Analysis
    • Loss Ratio
    • Delaware Corporation
    • Debt to GDP Ratio
    • Articles of Incorporation
    • Negative Covenants
    • Statutory Liquidity Ratio
    • Leverage Ratio for Banks
    • Accrued Liabilities
    • Activity Ratio
    • Debt Service Coverage Ratio
    • Return on Investment Ratio
    • Turnover Ratios
    • Cash Conversion Cycle
    • Lumion vs V-Ray
    • Capital Intensive
    • Voided Check
    • Negotiable Instruments
    • Portfolio Optimization
    • 401k Plan
    • Non-Marketable Securities
    • Stock Certificate
    • Treasury Stock
    • Appropriate Retained Earnings
    • Stockholder
    • Share Vesting
    • Shares Issued
    • Preferred Shares
    • Share Buyback
    • Shareholder Types
    • Tax Loss Harvesting
    • Statutory Audit
    • Audit Risk
    • Fund of Funds
    • Accredited Investor
    • Cost Centre
    • Lessee
    • Golden Handcuffs
    • Ordinary Shares
    • Restricted Stock Units
    • Goodwill Valuation
    • Share Classes
    • Lessor
    • Preferred Dividends
    • LIFO Liquidation
    • Dilutive Securities
    • Restructuring Cost
    • Non-Cumulative Preference Shares
    • Pass Through Entity
    • Management Discussion and Analysis
    • Premium on Stock
    • Leveraged Loans
    • Dividend
    • Dividend Policy
    • Financial Reporting Objectives
    • Financial Reporting
    • Internal Controls
    • Capital Investment
    • Debt to Equity Ratio
    • Dividend Growth Rate
    • Market Capitalization
    • Deal Origination
    • Importance of Working Capital
    • SWOT Analysis
    • White Knight
    • Root Cause Analysis
    • Realized Gain
    • Return on Operating Assets
    • Offshore Investments
    • Transfer Price
    • Times Interest Earned Ratio
    • Debt Coverage Ratio
    • Dividend Discount Model
    • Combined Ratio
    • Merger Arbitrage
    • Gordon Growth Model
    • Advantages of Joint Venture
    • Interest Coverage Ratio
    • Reserve Requirements
    • Asset Turnover Ratio
    • Price to Rent Ratio
    • Ratio Analysis Types
    • Debt Ratio
    • Business Risk
    • Financial Leverage
    • Dividend Payout Ratio
    • Mistakes in DCF
    • Risk/Reward Ratio
    • Full Form of FIPB
    • Financial Risk
    • CAPE Ratio
    • Overcapitalization
    • Systematic Risk
    • Hedge Ratio
    • Full Form of NHB
    • Sensitivity Analysis
    • Current Ratio
    • Corporation Examples
    • Asset to Sales Ratio
    • Balance Sheet Ratios
    • List of Financial Ratios
    • Coverage Ratio
    • Forward PE Ratio
    • Interpretation of Debt to Equity Ratio
    • Capitalization Ratio
    • Importance of Ratio Analysis
    • Quick Ratio Interpretation
    • Corporate Finance Basics
    • PEG Ratio
    • Corporate Finance Interview Questions
    • Price to Earnings Ratio
    • Structured Note
    • Limitations of Ratio Analysis
    • NPV vs IRR
    • IRR vs ROI
    • Imputed Interest
    • Full Form of HR
    • Shareholders Agreement
    • Earnings Per Share
    • Corporate Finance Jobs
    • About Corporate Finance
    • Corporate Finance Theory & Practices
    • Career in Corporate Finance
    • Simple Interest Rate vs Compound Interest Rate
    • Stocks vs Shares
    • Bonds vs Debenture
    • Bull Market vs Bear Market
    • Mortgagee vs Mortgagor
    • Horizontal Integration vs Vertical Integration
    • Money Market vs Capital Market
    • Leveraged vs Unleveraged
    • Dividends vs Capital Gains
    • Present Value vs Net Present Value
    • Qualified vs Ordinary Dividends
    • ROE vs ROA
    • Bond vs Loan
    • Stock Dividend vs Stock Split
    • Audit vs Assurance
    • Coupon Rate vs Interest Rate
    • Growth Stock vs Value Stock
  • Accounting fundamentals (614+)
  • Asset Management Tutorial (181+)
  • Banking (43+)
  • Credit Research Fundamentals (6+)
  • Economics (44+)
  • Finance Formula (382+)
  • Financial Modeling in Excel (13+)
  • Investment Banking Basics (114+)
  • Investment Banking Careers (26+)
  • Trading for dummies (67+)
  • valuation basics (27+)
Finance Blog Courses
  • Online Business Valuation Training
  • Equity Research Certification
  • Project Finance Course
Footer
About Us
  • Blog
  • Who is EDUCBA?
  • Sign Up
  • Live Classes
  • Corporate Training
  • Certificate from Top Institutions
  • Contact Us
  • Verifiable Certificate
  • Reviews
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  •  
Apps
  • iPhone & iPad
  • Android
Resources
  • Free Courses
  • Investment Banking Jobs Offer
  • Finance Formula
  • All Tutorials
Certification Courses
  • All Courses
  • Financial Analyst All in One Bundle
  • Investment Banking Training
  • Financial Modeling Course
  • Equity Research Course
  • Private Equity Training Course
  • Business Valuation Course
  • Mergers and Acquisitions Course

© 2022 - EDUCBA. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. THE CERTIFICATION NAMES ARE THE TRADEMARKS OF THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS.

EDUCBA
Free Investment Banking Course

Corporate Valuation, Investment Banking, Accounting, CFA Calculator & others

*Please provide your correct email id. Login details for this Free course will be emailed to you

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

EDUCBA
Free Investment Banking Course

Corporate Valuation, Investment Banking, Accounting, CFA Calculator & others

*Please provide your correct email id. Login details for this Free course will be emailed to you

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Let’s Get Started

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Loading . . .
Quiz
Question:

Answer:

Quiz Result
Total QuestionsCorrect AnswersWrong AnswersPercentage

Explore 1000+ varieties of Mock tests View more

EDUCBA Login

Forgot Password?

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

This website or its third-party tools use cookies, which are necessary to its functioning and required to achieve the purposes illustrated in the cookie policy. By closing this banner, scrolling this page, clicking a link or continuing to browse otherwise, you agree to our Privacy Policy

EDUCBA

*Please provide your correct email id. Login details for this Free course will be emailed to you

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Special Offer - Online Business Valuation Training Learn More